-
Harvest Intensity Effects on Carbon Stocks and Biodiversity Are Dependent on Regional Climate in Douglas-fir Forests of British Columbia
This paper investigates how different forest harvesting methods impact both the amount of carbon stored and the variety of plant and tree life. The study compared the effects of clearcutting, varying levels of partial tree retention, and no harvestin...This paper investigates how different forest harvesting methods impact both the amount of carbon stored and the variety of plant and tree life. The study compared the effects of clearcutting, varying levels of partial tree retention, and no harvesting across different climatic regions in British Columbia's Douglas-fir forests, ranging from humid to semi-arid. The central finding is that the intensity of harvesting significantly influences carbon storage and biodiversity, but importantly, the magnitude of these effects is strongly linked to the regional climate. -
Carbon Sequestration in Managed Temperate Coniferous Forests Under Climate Change
This paper explores the future of carbon storage within these vital ecosystems of British Columbia. Using a computer model, the researchers investigated how interactions between tree species, fire, forest management, and a changing climate might affe...This paper explores the future of carbon storage within these vital ecosystems of British Columbia. Using a computer model, the researchers investigated how interactions between tree species, fire, forest management, and a changing climate might affect the ability of these forests to absorb and store carbon until 2050. A key aspect of their work was the introduction of a new metric, net sector productivity, which offers a more comprehensive way to account for carbon by including not only forest ecosystems but also harvested wood products. The study aimed to provide a better understanding for developing effective climate change mitigation and adaptive management strategies in these forests. -
Combining Thinning and Diverse Plantings to Adapt to Climate Change Induced Timber Supply Shortage in British Columbia
This paper explores strategies to mitigate timber supply shortages in British Columbia (BC), a problem exacerbated by climate change and past natural disturbances like the mountain pine beetle outbreak. The authors investigate two primary forest mana...This paper explores strategies to mitigate timber supply shortages in British Columbia (BC), a problem exacerbated by climate change and past natural disturbances like the mountain pine beetle outbreak. The authors investigate two primary forest management approaches: commercial thinning and diverse plantings, including assisted species migration. By simulating the long-term effects of these interventions in a case study area, the study concludes that combining commercial thinning with species diversification offers the most promising solution to sustain future timber supply in BC, emphasizing the importance of adaptive forest management in the face of environmental challenges. -
Stand-Level Fuel Reduction Treatments and Fire Behaviour in Canadian Boreal Conifer Forest
This paper reviews the effectiveness of stand-level fuel reduction treatments in Canadian boreal conifer forests, specifically focusing on black spruce, jack pine, and lodgepole pine. These treatments, which involve thinning trees, pruning lower bran...This paper reviews the effectiveness of stand-level fuel reduction treatments in Canadian boreal conifer forests, specifically focusing on black spruce, jack pine, and lodgepole pine. These treatments, which involve thinning trees, pruning lower branches, and removing understory vegetation, aim to mitigate the risk of fast-spreading, high-intensity crown fires that are naturally prevalent in these ecosystems. While these fuel treatments generally reduce modeled and observed fire behavior under low to moderate fire weather, evidence suggests they become ineffective under very high or extreme fire conditions, especially when combined with high surface fuel loads and the relatively short stature of boreal conifers. The authors highlight the need for further research into managing surface fuel loads, exploring alternative fuel configurations, and integrating these treatments with broader fire suppression strategies. -
Perspectives - Six Opportunities to Improve Understanding of Fuel Treatment Longevity in Historically Frequent-Fire Forests
This paper addresses the critical need for improved understanding of the long-term effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments in dry, fire-prone forests of western North America. The authors highlight that current knowledge limitations lead to ineffi...This paper addresses the critical need for improved understanding of the long-term effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments in dry, fire-prone forests of western North America. The authors highlight that current knowledge limitations lead to inefficient maintenance and inaccurate wildfire forecasting. They propose six key research opportunities designed to refine our grasp of how long treatments remain effective. These opportunities include evaluating longevity within specific management goals, referencing desired ecological conditions, accounting for natural forest variability, exploring internal treatment factors, increasing post-treatment sampling frequency, and incorporating spatial heterogeneity into analyses. The paper aims to foster climate-adaptive management that enhances dry forest resilience to wildfire through more efficient and informed treatment strategies. -
Fire Treatment Effects on Vegetation, Structure, Fuels, and Potential Fire Severity in Western U.S. Forests
This paper investigates the effectiveness of various fire management treatments on western U. S. coniferous forests, which have become more susceptible to severe wildfires due to a century of fire exclusion and altered land use. Researchers analyzed ...This paper investigates the effectiveness of various fire management treatments on western U. S. coniferous forests, which have become more susceptible to severe wildfires due to a century of fire exclusion and altered land use. Researchers analyzed the impacts of mechanical thinning, prescribed burning, and a combination of both across six diverse sites. The study found that mechanical thinning combined with prescribed fire was the most effective strategy for significantly reducing surface fuel loads, decreasing the likelihood of severe crown fires, and lowering predicted tree mortality. While mechanical-only treatments were less consistent, they were effective when whole-tree harvesting systems were used, minimizing residual surface fuels. -
Context-Dependent Disturbance Synergies - Subcortical Competitors May Constrain Bark Beetle Outbreaks Following Wildfires
This paper explores how wildfires and beetle communities interact to influence Douglas-fir beetle outbreaks in British Columbia's forests. Traditionally, DFB populations are expected to surge after fires due to an abundance of weakened trees, but th...This paper explores how wildfires and beetle communities interact to influence Douglas-fir beetle outbreaks in British Columbia's forests. Traditionally, DFB populations are expected to surge after fires due to an abundance of weakened trees, but this study reveals a more complex dynamic. The presence of woodboring beetles, which also colonize fire-injured trees, can significantly constrain DFB population growth through interspecific competition. Specifically, when woodborers infest over 50% of trees in a stand, DFB reproduction falls below replacement levels, suggesting that these competitors can suppress potential DFB irruptions and ultimately influence forest resilience after disturbances. -
Applying Resilience Concepts in Forest Management - A Retrospective Simulation Approach
This paper investigates how different forest management strategies impact the resilience of forests facing climate change, specifically a mountain pine beetle outbreak in British Columbia. The authors use a retrospective simulation approach from 1980...This paper investigates how different forest management strategies impact the resilience of forests facing climate change, specifically a mountain pine beetle outbreak in British Columbia. The authors use a retrospective simulation approach from 1980 to 2060 to compare business as usual practices with two alternative strategies: one focused on increasing the diversity of replanted trees, and another that combined early harvesting of susceptible pine with diversified reforestation. The study assesses resilience by examining ecological factors like growing stock and tree species diversity, alongside socio-economic indicators such as timber flow stability and net revenue, concluding that proactive management enhancing diversity and reducing high-risk species leads to greater overall forest resilience in the face of climate-related disturbances. -
Future Fire Risk and the Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Potential of Forest Rehabilitation in British Columbia, Canada
This paper investigates the interplay between future wildfire risk and the greenhouse gas mitigation potential of rehabilitating forests in British Columbia, Canada. Using modeling that simulates future fire scenarios and tracks carbon in forests an...This paper investigates the interplay between future wildfire risk and the greenhouse gas mitigation potential of rehabilitating forests in British Columbia, Canada. Using modeling that simulates future fire scenarios and tracks carbon in forests and harvested wood products, the study assesses whether post-fire salvage logging and replanting can lead to a net reduction in GHG emissions compared to natural regeneration. The authors explore the conditions under which these rehabilitation efforts yield climate benefits and compare this potential mitigation against the substantial GHG emissions from the projected increase in wildfires, questioning if resources might be better directed towards preventing fires in the first place. -
Performance of Planted Engelmann Spruce and Subalpine Fir Seedlings in British Columbia's Southern Mountains
This paper details a study conducted in the southern mountains of British Columbia to assess the survival and growth of planted Engelmann spruce and subalpine fir seedlings in different sizes of harvested forest openings. The researchers compared see...This paper details a study conducted in the southern mountains of British Columbia to assess the survival and growth of planted Engelmann spruce and subalpine fir seedlings in different sizes of harvested forest openings. The researchers compared seedling performance across various silvicultural systems, noting that survival generally decreased with smaller opening sizes, while growth was best in larger clearcuts. The study aimed to provide insights into effective regeneration practices for high-elevation forests, considering factors like opening size, local climate, and species response. -
Recent Crown Thinning in a Boreal Black Spruce Forest Does Not Reduce Spread Rate nor Total Fuel Consumption - Results from an Experimental Crown Fire in Alberta, Canada
This paper details an experimental crown fire conducted in an Alberta, Canada, boreal black spruce forest to assess the effectiveness of recent crown thinning as a fuel treatment. Researchers ignited a 3. 6-hectare fire, observing its behavior in bot...This paper details an experimental crown fire conducted in an Alberta, Canada, boreal black spruce forest to assess the effectiveness of recent crown thinning as a fuel treatment. Researchers ignited a 3. 6-hectare fire, observing its behavior in both untreated and thinned sections. The key finding was that while thinning led to a significant reduction in fire intensity, it did not reduce the fire's spread rate nor total fuel consumption. This suggests that in dense boreal black spruce with high surface fuel loads and low crown base heights, thinning alone may not prevent the rapid progression of crown fires, but it could potentially aid suppression efforts by reducing the intensity. -
Commercial Thinning Effects on Growth, Yield and Mortality in Natural Lodgepole Pine Stands in Alberta
This study investigates how commercial thinning impacts the growth, yield, and mortality of natural lodgepole pine forests in Alberta, Canada. Faced with a predicted timber shortage due to fires and mountain pine beetle infestations, the research exp...This study investigates how commercial thinning impacts the growth, yield, and mortality of natural lodgepole pine forests in Alberta, Canada. Faced with a predicted timber shortage due to fires and mountain pine beetle infestations, the research explores thinning as a strategy to increase mid-term sawlog supply by accelerating tree growth and enabling earlier timber access. The findings reveal that while thinned stands initially show less volume, they ultimately demonstrate a greater cumulative volume gain when factoring in the wood removed during thinning. This benefit stems from increased individual tree diameter and live crown ratio for remaining trees and a significant reduction in overall tree mortality, particularly among smaller trees. -
Ecosystem Management in Paludified Boreal Forests - Enhancing Wood Production, Biodiversity, and Carbon Sequestration at the Landscape Level
This paper examines ecosystem management strategies for the paludified boreal forests of Canada, emphasizing how to simultaneously enhance wood production, biodiversity, and carbon sequestration. The authors delve into how natural disturbances, parti...This paper examines ecosystem management strategies for the paludified boreal forests of Canada, emphasizing how to simultaneously enhance wood production, biodiversity, and carbon sequestration. The authors delve into how natural disturbances, particularly fire severity, influence forest dynamics, soil properties, and the diversity of plant and invertebrate communities. They then contrast these natural processes with the impacts of different logging methods on soil, productivity, and understory vegetation, highlighting how traditional clearcutting and careful logging compare to natural fire regimes. Finally, the paper discusses the critical role of these forests in carbon sequestration and proposes management approaches that emulate natural disturbances to maintain old-growth forest characteristics and mitigate climate change. -
Seedling Response Following Partial Cutting in Lodgepole Pine Forests on Caribou Winter Range in West-Central British Columbia
This paper details a study examining how different forestry practices, specifically partial cutting methods like group selection and irregular group shelterwood, impact the survival and growth of planted lodgepole pine and interior spruce seedlings. ...This paper details a study examining how different forestry practices, specifically partial cutting methods like group selection and irregular group shelterwood, impact the survival and growth of planted lodgepole pine and interior spruce seedlings. The research compared these outcomes to those in clearcut areas, with the overarching goal of identifying silvicultural systems that can maintain suitable habitat for northern caribou, which rely on terrestrial and arboreal lichens found in these forests. By analyzing seedling survival and growth over five years in relation to different harvesting techniques, the study aimed to determine if partial cutting could effectively regenerate desired tree species while minimizing negative effects on critical caribou forage. The findings provide insights into balancing timber harvesting with the ecological needs of threatened caribou populations in this region. -
Prioritizing Commercial Thinning Quantification of Growth and Competition with High-Density Drone Laser Scanning
This document introduces a method for prioritizing commercial thinning in forests by integrating high-density drone laser scanning (DLS) data with tree-ring measurements. This research uses DLS to quantify individual tree growth and competition, spec...This document introduces a method for prioritizing commercial thinning in forests by integrating high-density drone laser scanning (DLS) data with tree-ring measurements. This research uses DLS to quantify individual tree growth and competition, specifically identifying that crown volume is the strongest predictor of recent basal area growth. This innovative approach allows for the creation of detailed spatial maps, including a new "growth competition index," which can guide forest managers in optimizing thinning strategies across large areas, moving beyond traditional stand-level assessments to a more precise, intra-stand management. The study emphasizes how this technology provides timely, fine-scale information to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of silvicultural practices, particularly commercial thinning. -
Managing Wildlife Habitat Complex Interactions with Biotic and Abiotic Disturbances
This document investigates how partial harvesting strategies, designed to enhance mule deer habitat and allow timber extraction in British Columbia's dry Douglas-fir forests, impact complex interactions with natural disturbances like insect outbreaks...This document investigates how partial harvesting strategies, designed to enhance mule deer habitat and allow timber extraction in British Columbia's dry Douglas-fir forests, impact complex interactions with natural disturbances like insect outbreaks and wildfires. The study, spanning 30 years, found that while short-term harvesting altered forest structure and reduced the immediate risk of crown fires and Douglas-fir beetle infestations, many of these structural and susceptibility changes reverted over the long term. The removal of harvesting residuals proved more significant in mitigating long-term disturbance risks, particularly for Douglas-fir beetles and intense surface fires, than the time elapsed since the treatment itself. The authors conclude that sustainable forest management integrating timber extraction and mule deer habitat conservation is achievable if partial harvesting occurs at intervals of 30 years or less and residuals are promptly cleared. -
The National Fire and Fire Surrogate Study Effects of Fuel Treatments in the Western and Eastern United States After 20 Years
This paper presents the long-term ecological effects of forest fuel and restoration treatments from the ongoing national Fire and Fire Surrogate study, analyzing data collected over approximately 20 years across four diverse sites in the Western and...This paper presents the long-term ecological effects of forest fuel and restoration treatments from the ongoing national Fire and Fire Surrogate study, analyzing data collected over approximately 20 years across four diverse sites in the Western and Eastern United States. The central goal of the original FFS study was to evaluate how mechanical treatments and prescribed fire impact forest ecosystems by reducing fire hazard, promoting desirable fire-adapted species, and improving understory diversity. Key findings reveal that the most effective treatment varies significantly by region: mechanical treatments combined with fire yielded better long-term outcomes in Western pine-dominated forests, while prescribed burning alone proved more beneficial in Eastern hardwood-dominated forests. The authors conclude that to maintain these desirable conditions and achieve long-term resilience, treatments must be adapted to the specific ecosystem and followed up with repeated applications. -
Wildfire Facilitates Upslope Advance in a Shade-Intolerant but not a Shade-Tolerant Conifer
This paper investigates how wildfires influence the upward migration of tree species in California's subalpine forests, a phenomenon often linked to climate change. Researchers examined post-fire tree regeneration across various fire severities, focu...This paper investigates how wildfires influence the upward migration of tree species in California's subalpine forests, a phenomenon often linked to climate change. Researchers examined post-fire tree regeneration across various fire severities, focusing on the contrasting responses of shade-tolerant and shade-intolerant conifer species. While overall montane species regeneration decreased in burned areas, shade-intolerant Jeffrey pine showed increased success in severely burned plots, aligning with predictions of higher climatic suitability. Conversely, shade-tolerant red fir regeneration declined significantly with higher fire severity, suggesting that the specific regeneration niche of a species, its ideal post-fire conditions, is critical in determining whether fire facilitates or hinders its range expansion. -
Forest Thinning and Prescribed Burning Treatments Reduce Wildfire Severity and Buffer the Impacts of Severe Fire Weather
This paper investigates the effectiveness of different forest fuel treatments, such as thinning and prescribed burning, in reducing the severity of subsequent wildfires. Leveraging a unique 1200-hectare experiment that was later impacted by a signifi...This paper investigates the effectiveness of different forest fuel treatments, such as thinning and prescribed burning, in reducing the severity of subsequent wildfires. Leveraging a unique 1200-hectare experiment that was later impacted by a significant wildfire, the authors compared various treatment approaches, including thin-only, burn-only, and a combination of both, against an untreated control. Their analysis of fire severity metrics, considering pre-fire fuel conditions and fire weather, provides strong evidence that proactive fuel management, especially combining thinning and burning, significantly mitigates wildfire intensity and damage to trees, even decades after the treatments were implemented and under a range of weather conditions. The study supports the continued use of these treatments as valuable tools for forest restoration and enhancing resilience to increasingly severe wildfires. -
Diversifying Managed Forests to Increase Resilience
This paper investigates how diversifying managed forests in British Columbia could enhance their ability to recover from disturbances, specifically a recent mountain pine beetle epidemic linked to climate change. The authors used computer simulations...This paper investigates how diversifying managed forests in British Columbia could enhance their ability to recover from disturbances, specifically a recent mountain pine beetle epidemic linked to climate change. The authors used computer simulations to compare different forest management strategies over an 80-year period, assessing their impact on ecological resilience, timber supply, and economic outcomes. Their findings suggest that a strategy focused on proactively harvesting dominant, susceptible tree species and promoting a greater variety of planted and naturally regenerating trees leads to improved forest health, higher long-term harvest rates, and more stable economic returns without compromising economic viability. The study advocates for incorporating diversification as a key approach to increasing the resilience of managed forests in the face of future environmental challenges.